no comments on such a well rated formation? I am surprised there is no controversy. I myself very much like it but I hope discussion was not shoved under the carpet!

I dont really kno about this form. It looks nice. But it seems that you are vunerable to beasts and if you move your knight your cleric becomes exposed to witch and scouts.
The furgon placement seems well thought out though. :)

the furgon shall slow down the beasts and the dual frosts would be enough to rip them apart

and with the furgon to block most los from your flank then the scout should have to resort to going within lw range to attack ur frost, and then he just sacrificed his scout

personally i think its all very well done and i personally have used this for quite a while and see no problem with it

My only gripe with this setup is the furgon is in a poor position to be effective samesides in a few turns. And generally, same sides shrubbing is often vital and must be done quickly, if at all. It can be the difference between pressuring, or being pressured Just my opinion.

The frost position is very sound, perfect lw placement, great mud placement, apt distribution of knights. Good formation.